Beyond Conditionality versus Cooperation: Power and Resistance in the Case of EU Mobility Partnerships and Swiss Migration Partnerships

Details

Ressource 1Request a copyDownload: BIB_E0CC95303EB3.P001.pdf (221.54 [Ko])
State: Deleted
Version: author
Serval ID
serval:BIB_E0CC95303EB3
Type
Article: article from journal or magazin.
Collection
Publications
Institution
Title
Beyond Conditionality versus Cooperation: Power and Resistance in the Case of EU Mobility Partnerships and Swiss Migration Partnerships
Journal
Migration Studies
Author(s)
Kunz Rahel, Maisenbacher Julia
ISSN
2049-5838
Publication state
Published
Issued date
07/2013
Peer-reviewed
Oui
Volume
1
Number
2
Pages
196-220
Language
english
Abstract
Migration partnerships (MPs) have become a key instrument in global migration governance. In contrast to traditional unilateral approaches, MPs emphasize a more comprehensive and inclusive tackling of migration issues between countries of origin, transit, and destination. Due to this cooperation-oriented concept, most of the existing studies on MPs neglect power questions within partnerships in line with the official discourse, reflecting a broader trend in the international migration governance literature. Others take an instrumentalist view in analysing the power of partnerships or focus on soft power. Illustrated with the examples of the European Mobility Partnerships (EU MPs) and the Swiss Migration Partnerships (CH MPs), we conduct an analysis based on a concept of productive power drawing on post-structural and post-colonial insights. Our main argument is that in contrast to their seemingly consent-oriented and technical character, MPs are sites of intense (discursive) struggles, and (re-)produce meanings, subjects, and resistances. A productive power analysis allows us to move beyond the dichotomy in the literature between coercion and cooperation, as well as between power and resistance more broadly.
Keywords
international migration governance, migration partnerships, productive power, 'othering', resistance
Create date
26/08/2013 19:18
Last modification date
20/08/2019 17:05
Usage data