The gendering of excellence through quality criteria: the case of the SNSF Professorships in Switzerland
Details
Serval ID
serval:BIB_DC0562E6119C
Type
Article: article from journal or magazin.
Collection
Publications
Institution
Title
The gendering of excellence through quality criteria: the case of the SNSF Professorships in Switzerland
Journal
Tertiary Education and Management
ISSN
1358-3883 (Print,1573-1936)
Publication state
Published
Issued date
05/2013
Peer-reviewed
Oui
Volume
19
Number
3
Pages
189-204
Language
english
Abstract
The Swiss National Science Foundation Professorships Programme is presented as a
scientific programme that aims to promote outstanding young scholars to professorial
positions. Academic excellence is presented as the main selection criterion. The
emphasis put on the research portfolio and on the age of the candidates means that the
beneficiaries of these professorships put forward an image of excellence that is more
embedded in data-based sciences than in the humanities and social sciences, thus
strengthening the domination of a sector scientific activity essentially occupied by men
over the sector that has opened up more widely to women. This paper aims to
deconstruct the criteria of academic excellence as they appear in this programme and to
show that what seem quality criteria are in fact inspired by a specific androcentric
model. These biases tend to undermine the gender equality aims of the programme.
scientific programme that aims to promote outstanding young scholars to professorial
positions. Academic excellence is presented as the main selection criterion. The
emphasis put on the research portfolio and on the age of the candidates means that the
beneficiaries of these professorships put forward an image of excellence that is more
embedded in data-based sciences than in the humanities and social sciences, thus
strengthening the domination of a sector scientific activity essentially occupied by men
over the sector that has opened up more widely to women. This paper aims to
deconstruct the criteria of academic excellence as they appear in this programme and to
show that what seem quality criteria are in fact inspired by a specific androcentric
model. These biases tend to undermine the gender equality aims of the programme.
Keywords
National systems of higher education, Staff recruitment and retention, Academic careers, Gender inequalities, Professorship, Excellence criteria
Create date
01/03/2013 14:01
Last modification date
20/08/2019 16:00
Usage data
