De l'importance conservee de l'approche clinique. Reflets d'une collaboration regionale entre generalistes, internistes et cardiologues. [Continuing importance of the clinical approach. Observations on a regional collaboration between general practitioners, internists and cardiologists]

Details

Serval ID
serval:BIB_3F04E355F99E
Type
Article: article from journal or magazin.
Collection
Publications
Institution
Title
De l'importance conservee de l'approche clinique. Reflets d'une collaboration regionale entre generalistes, internistes et cardiologues. [Continuing importance of the clinical approach. Observations on a regional collaboration between general practitioners, internists and cardiologists]
Journal
Schweizerische Medizinische Wochenschrift
Author(s)
Jaussi  A.
ISSN
0036-7672 (Print)
Publication state
Published
Issued date
11/1994
Volume
124
Number
45
Pages
2049-52
Notes
Comparative Study
English Abstract
Journal Article --- Old month value: Nov 12
Abstract
The advent of high-tech diagnostic methods raises concerns nowadays about the value of the clinical approach and bedside diagnosis. This at least is the impression given by modern scientific literature, which rarely even mentions this part of examination of the patient. In order to define the actual role played by auscultation in the management of cardiological patients by the primary care physician, the records of 250 patients consecutively referred to a cardiologist are analyzed. The practitioner's initial clinical diagnosis is compared to the final cardiological diagnosis. Per referred patient, 1.76 specialized consultations were needed. In 64% of the cases only one such consultation took place. Initial diagnosis was correct in 80% of all cases, partly correct in 11% and incorrect in 9% of the cases. Out of the 64 cases of valvular diseases, 33 were initially correctly recognized by the physician. The cardiological investigation was also invasive in 6.5% of all cases, 4.5% of the patients eventually undergoing invasive or surgical treatment. Thus the great majority of the patients (93.5%) were managed by the primary physician with "first-line" cardiologist's support, which was often only occasional (only one specialized consultation in about two thirds of all cases). This highly independent and presumably cost-effective patient management by the primary care physician implies a high level of clinical skill. It stresses the outstanding importance of continuing teaching of the clinical approach and particularly of cardiac auscultation, which is still the best screening method for valvular heart disease.
Keywords
Adult Aged Cardiology Clinical Competence *Family Practice Female Heart Auscultation Heart Diseases/*diagnosis Heart Function Tests Humans Internal Medicine Male Middle Aged Referral and Consultation
Pubmed
Web of science
Create date
28/01/2008 12:54
Last modification date
20/08/2019 14:36
Usage data