The use of social networking sites like LinkedIn in recruitment is ubiquitous. This practice may hold risks for older job seekers. Not having grown up using the Internet and having learned how to use social media only in middle adulthood may render them less versed in online self-presentation than younger job seekers. Results of this research show some differences and many similarities between younger and older job seekers’ impression management on their LinkedIn profiles. Nevertheless, independently of their impression management efforts, older job seekers received less job offers than younger job seekers. Only using a profile photo with a younger appearance reduced this bias. Implications for the role of job seeker age in online impression management and recruitment are discussed.