Analysis of patient physical restraints usage in a Swiss emergency service

Details

Serval ID
serval:BIB_7E20490010A8
Type
Inproceedings: an article in a conference proceedings.
Publication sub-type
Abstract (Abstract): shot summary in a article that contain essentials elements presented during a scientific conference, lecture or from a poster.
Collection
Publications
Institution
Title
Analysis of patient physical restraints usage in a Swiss emergency service
Title of the conference
Gemeinsame Jahrestagung Schweizerische Gesellschaft für Intensivmedizin Schweizerische Gesellschaft für Pulmonale Hypertonie Gesellschaft für klinische Ernährung der Schweiz Schweizerische Gesellschaft für Notfall- und Rettungsmedizin Schweizerische Interessengemeinschaft für Intensivpflege Gast: Schweizerische Interessengemeinschaft Notfallpflege
Author(s)
Beysard N., Carron P.N., Trueb L., Meier L., Wintz G., Yersin B.
ISBN
1424-4985
ISSN-L
1424-4977
Publication state
Published
Issued date
2011
Volume
11
Series
Swiss Medical Forum
Pages
6S
Language
english
Abstract
Introduction: Emergency services (ES) are often faced with agitated,confused or aggressive patients. Such situations may require physicalrestraint. The prevalence of these measures is poorly documented,concerning 1 to 10% of patients admitted in the ES. The indications forrestraint, the context and the related complications are poorly studied.The emergency service and the security service of our hospital havedocumented physical restraint for several years, using specific protocolsintegrated into the medical records. The study evaluated the magnitudeof the problem, the patient characteristics, and degree of adherence tothe restraint protocol.Methods: Retrospective study of physical restraint used on adultpatients in the ES in 2009. The study included analysis of medical anddemographic characteristics, indications justifying restraint and qualityof restraint documentation. Patients were identified from computerizedES and security service records. The data were supplemented byexamination of patients' medical records.Results: In 2009, according to the security service, 390 patients (1%)were physically restrained in the ES. The ES computerized systemidentified only 196 patients. Most patients were male (62%). The medianage was 40 years (15-98 years; P90 = 80 years). 63 % of the situationsoccurred between 18h00 and 6h00, and most frequently on Saturday(19%). Substance or alcohol abuse was present in 48.7% of cases andacute psychiatric crisis was mentioned in 16.7%. In most cases,restraint was motivated by extreme agitation or auto / hetero-aggressiveviolence. Most patients (68 %) were restrained with upper limb andabdominal restraints. More than three anatomic restraints werenecessary in 52 % of the patients. Intervention of security guards wasrequired in 77% of the cases. 61 restraint protocols (31 %) were missingand 57% of the records were incomplete. In many cases, the protocolsdid not include the signature of the physician (22%) or of the nurse(43.8%). Medical records analysis did not allow reliable estimation ofthe number of restraint-induced complications.Conclusions: Physical restraint is most often motivated by majoragitation and/or secondary to substance abuse. Caregivers regularlycall security guards for help. Restraint documentation is often missing orincomplete, requiring major improvement in education and prescription.
Create date
18/01/2012 16:32
Last modification date
20/08/2019 14:39
Usage data