Implementation of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Perspectives from Deliberative Democracy

Details

Ressource 1Download: 19TrinityCLRev214.pdf (1404.06 [Ko])
State: Public
Version: Final published version
License: Not specified
Serval ID
serval:BIB_45F598168691
Type
Article: article from journal or magazin.
Collection
Publications
Title
Implementation of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights Perspectives from Deliberative Democracy
Journal
Trinity College Law Review
Author(s)
Pastor y Camarasa Alicia
ISSN-L
1393-5941
Publication state
Published
Issued date
2016
Volume
19
Pages
214-233
Language
english
Abstract
The practical difficulties of judicialising ESCRs often overshadow the conceptual barriers. Enforcing ESCRs naturally provokes questions about the fair allocation of scarce resources. Without unlimited resources, governments and policymakers must inevitably prioritise certain rights over others, selectively allocating resources to further only a handful of causes. This style of decision-making, it will be seen, often unfairly restricts the benefits of ESCRs to certain sections of the population. This essay argues that many of these practical injustices stem from an inadequate institutional framework. An institutional framework that leaves ESCRs unenforced and unenforceable calls into question their status as human rights. The purpose of this essay is manifold: it aims to analyse the issues raised by the implementation of ESCRs and then forward the notion that these difficulties could be circumvented by reinterpreting the implementation of ESCRs from the perspective of deliberative democracy. This essay is divided into three parts. The first part outlines the two major issues facing the implementation of ESCRs. The second part offers a critique of the current model of representative democracy in the context of the implementation of ESCRs. Following the seminal work of Habermas, Gutmann and Thompson, the second part continues by outlining the principles of deliberative democracy that will be tested in the third part. Finally, after considering some of the most compelling arguments raised by opponents of the judicialisation of ESCRs, the third part offers a fresh approach to the question of the implementation of ESCRs by exploring heterodox institutional engineering. It will be argued that mechanisms of deliberative democracy could circumvent many of the barriers raised against ESCRs.
Keywords
Economic social and cultural rights, Deliberative democracy, human rights
Create date
10/08/2023 10:50
Last modification date
16/08/2023 11:24
Usage data